Dementia and Mental Capacity: Who Decides, and When Does the Court of Protection Get Involved?

A dementia diagnosis does not remove anyone’s right to decide. Capacity is judged decision by decision, at the time the choice must be made. If a person cannot decide, others must act in their best interests. The Court of Protection steps in when there is a dispute, serious doubt or a need for formal authority.

What does a dementia diagnosis mean for someone’s right to decide?

A diagnosis does not take away anyone’s say. Dementia and mental capacity are linked, but they are not the same thing. Many people with dementia can still make everyday choices, and some can make major ones too.

If you care for someone with dementia, you may be facing hard questions about care, treatment or where they live. We wrote this guide to help you understand who decides, how capacity is checked, and when the court gets involved.

Having dementia is not the same as lacking capacity.

How does dementia affect mental capacity?

Dementia affects how the brain works. For some people that means memory loss. For others it changes reasoning, language or judgement. Symptoms and stages vary a lot from person to person. For clinical detail, the NHS and the Alzheimer’s Society are the right places to look. We focus on the law.

Dementia and loss of capacity do not happen all at once. Ability often changes over time. It can also vary through the day, or with tiredness, pain, infection or stress. A person may struggle in the evening and cope well after a good morning.

This is why the law looks at the individual and the moment. The Mental Capacity Act 2005 sets out the rules in England and Wales. It covers decisions about health, welfare and money. This guide focuses on health and welfare decisions, such as where someone lives, what care they get and what treatment they receive.

Capacity can change, so a single assessment may not last forever.

Is capacity decision-specific? (Having dementia does not mean losing all capacity)

Yes. Capacity is tied to one decision at a time. The Act assumes an adult has capacity unless shown otherwise.

Here is an example. Margaret has dementia. She can say clearly that she wants her daughter to visit every Sunday. She understands who her daughter is and what the visits mean to her. But she cannot grasp the risks of a complex surgical procedure. She has capacity about contact, but may lack capacity about that treatment.

The same applies across different areas of life. Capacity is usually considered separately for:

  • where the person lives (residence)
  • what care they receive
  • who they see (contact)
  • medical treatment

Each area needs its own question. A conclusion about one does not settle the others.

Why are unwise decisions not proof of incapacity?

We often hear families say, “He is making a terrible choice, so he must lack capacity.” The law says otherwise. A person can make a decision that others think is unwise, risky or odd. That alone does not show a lack of capacity.

The question is how the person reaches the decision, not whether you agree with it. Can they understand the information, retain it long enough, use or weigh it, and communicate a choice? If so, the choice is theirs.

Assess the decision-making process, not whether the outcome seems sensible.

What are the five principles behind the Mental Capacity Act?

Section 1 of the Act sets out five principles. They guide every assessment and every decision made afterwards. They say:

  1. Assume a person has capacity unless it is shown that they do not.
  2. Give all practical help before deciding they cannot decide.
  3. A person is not unable to decide just because their choice seems unwise.
  4. If you decide for someone, act in their best interests.
  5. Choose the option that restricts their rights and freedom the least.

These principles are useful when you disagree with a professional. If no one has tried to help the person decide, the second principle has not been met. You can raise that point calmly and in writing.

Support comes before any finding of incapacity.

How does the law test for loss of capacity?

The law asks two connected questions. Both must be answered before someone is treated as lacking capacity for a decision.

  • The functional question (section 3(1)): can the person understand, retain, use or weigh the relevant information, and communicate their decision?
  • The causative question (section 2(1)): if they cannot, is that because of an impairment of, or disturbance in, how their mind or brain works, such as dementia?

The link between the two is essential. Lawyers call it the causative nexus. The Court of Appeal explored it in PC and NC v City of York Council [2013] EWCA Civ 478.

In A Local Authority v JB [2021] UKSC 52, the Supreme Court said the functional question should normally be asked first. Only then should the assessor ask whether the impairment causes any inability. This keeps the focus on what the person can actually do, rather than on their diagnosis.

We keep this in mind when we examine assessment evidence. A report that lists a diagnosis but never explains why it affects the decision falls short.

A diagnosis alone is never enough. The impairment must explain why the person cannot decide.

Who assesses capacity in dementia?

The person who will make the decision, or carry out the action, usually assesses capacity. That is often not a doctor.

  • A GP, consultant or nurse often assesses medical treatment decisions.
  • A social worker often assesses care and where someone lives.
  • A care home manager or support worker may assess day-to-day choices.
  • A specialist, such as a psychiatrist or psychologist, may be asked when the picture is complex.
  • A court-appointed expert may give independent evidence when the court needs it.

An Independent Mental Capacity Advocate (IMCA) supports people who have no suitable family or friends to consult. IMCAs must be involved when the NHS or a local authority proposes serious medical treatment or a long-term move into a hospital or care home. They do not decide capacity, but they speak up for the person.

What are the four steps of a good assessment?

A careful assessor works through the same steps each time:

  1. Identify the exact decision to be made.
  2. Give the person the information and support they need, in a way that suits them.
  3. Test the four abilities: understand, retain, use or weigh, and communicate.
  4. Decide whether any inability is because of the impairment, and record the reasons.

Good practice includes choosing the best time of day, a quiet setting and familiar faces. You can help by telling the assessor what works well for your relative.

Clear reasoning matters too. AMDC v AG [2020] EWCOP 58 concerned a woman living with dementia. In it, the court gave guidance on how to write capacity reports. Reports should show the work behind each conclusion, address each decision separately, and explain the practical steps taken to help the person decide. If an assessment does not show this, you can ask for the details.

A sound assessment is specific, supported and written down.

What if I disagree with a capacity assessment?

Start by asking for the assessment in writing. Check that it names the decision, explains the support given and links any inability to dementia. Ask whether the person was seen at their best time.

Then you can request a second opinion, use the local authority’s complaints route, or ask for a meeting with the care team. If the disagreement continues, our mental capacity solicitors can advise you on whether to ask the court to decide.

How are decisions made when someone can no longer decide? (Best interests)

When someone cannot make a particular decision, another person must make it for them. This is where making decisions for someone with dementia becomes a legal duty, not just a family choice. The decision-maker depends on the situation. It may be a doctor for treatment, a social worker or local authority for care arrangements, or an attorney if one was appointed.

Dementia best interests decisions follow a checklist in section 4 of the Act. The decision-maker must:

  • consider whether the person may regain capacity, and when
  • involve the person as much as possible
  • take account of their past and present wishes, feelings, beliefs and values
  • consult family, carers and others who know them well
  • avoid assumptions based on age, appearance, condition or behaviour

Best interests is not what the family prefers, and it is not what is easiest for the professionals. It is a structured view of what suits the person, with their voice at the centre.

What difference does a health and welfare LPA make?

A health and welfare lasting power of attorney lets someone choose, in advance, who will make these decisions if they lose capacity. A person can make only one while they still have capacity. It must be registered with the Office of the Public Guardian before it can be used. It only applies once the person lacks capacity for the decision in question. An attorney can only decide about life-sustaining treatment if the LPA expressly gives them that power.

We do not act on LPAs, so we suggest you seek advice from a specialist adviser if this applies to you.

Without an LPA, relatives have no automatic right to decide. Families are consulted, but the professional decision-maker makes the final decision. Many people are surprised by this.

What about care that limits someone’s freedom?

Sometimes care involves restrictions, such as locked doors or constant supervision. These may amount to a deprivation of liberty, which needs legal authorisation:

  • In a care home or hospital, authorisation usually comes through the Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards (DoLS), granted by the local authority.
  • In other settings, such as supported living or the person’s own home, the Court of Protection must authorise it.

DoLS remains the system in force. The government has said it will consult on replacing DoLS with the Liberty Protection Safeguards. If you have concerns about restrictions on a relative, our DoLS solicitors can advise.

Best interests decisions must be structured, consultative and focused on the person’s own wishes.

When does the Court of Protection get involved in dementia cases?

Most decisions never reach court. The court becomes involved when nothing else can resolve the issue. Dementia and the Court of Protection most often meet in these situations:

  • The family and professionals disagree about care or treatment.
  • There is real doubt about whether the person has capacity.
  • A move to a care home is contested.
  • Someone is, or may be, deprived of their liberty.
  • Medical treatment is serious or finely balanced.
  • A relative’s contact is being restricted.

The court can decide on capacity, make a best interests decision, or approve arrangements that limit freedom. In urgent cases, it can act quickly. We can bring an emergency Court of Protection application when delay would put the person at risk.

What if my family disagrees with professionals?

Try these steps in order:

  1. Ask for a best interests meeting and attend it.
  2. Share your relative’s past wishes, values and routines.
  3. Put your concerns in writing.
  4. Ask what less restrictive options were considered.
  5. Seek advice from our health and welfare solicitors if the disagreement continues.

The court is not a punishment. It provides a clear, lawful answer when people see things differently.

When does the court order a fresh assessment?

The court does not simply accept every report. It may order a new assessment when the evidence conflicts, the assessment appears incomplete, or the person’s condition has changed. It may also want one when the first assessor did not show what support was offered.

Under section 49 of the Act, the court can require a report from the Public Guardian or a Court of Protection Visitor. It can also direct a local authority or NHS body to arrange a report from one of its staff. For independent expert evidence, Practice Direction 15A sets out how the court gives permission and instructs an expert. The expert is often a single joint expert, and the court controls who is appointed and what questions they answer.

The court decides, and it can ask for better evidence before it does.

How can Welford help with dementia and mental capacity?

We act only in health and welfare matters in the Court of Protection and under the Mental Health Act. For families facing dementia and mental capacity questions, we can:

  • advise on whether a capacity assessment is sound
  • explain your rights in a best interests process
  • challenge decisions about care, residence or contact
  • help with DoLS and deprivation of liberty issues
  • bring urgent applications to the court
  • check whether you qualify for legal aid for Court of Protection work

We do not act on property and financial affairs, deputyship, statutory wills, LPAs or compensation claims. If you need help with those, we will tell you plainly. Where a relative also has mental health needs, our mental health solicitors can advise.

We help families understand where they stand and what comes next.

What are the main points to remember about dementia and capacity?

  • A diagnosis does not remove the right to decide.
  • Capacity is judged for each decision, at the time it is made.
  • The assessor must give support first and record the reasons.
  • Unwise choices do not prove incapacity.
  • Best interests decisions must reflect the person’s own wishes and values.
  • The Court of Protection resolves disputes and gives lawful authority.

Worried about a capacity decision? Speak to our specialist team today

If a relative with dementia has been found to lack capacity, or a decision about their care, home or contact does not feel right, do not wait for it to become fixed. The sooner you get advice, the more options you are likely to have.

Call 0116 274 5252, email info@welfordsolicitors.co.uk or send us a message. Our specialist solicitors will review the assessment, explain your relative’s and your rights, and tell you whether the Court of Protection can help. We check legal aid eligibility from your first call, and we act urgently when a move, restriction or treatment decision is imminent.
 


Frequently Asked Questions

Can someone with dementia still make their own decisions?
Yes. Dementia and mental capacity are not the same thing. The Mental Capacity Act 2005 presumes every adult has capacity, and each decision is looked at separately. Many people with dementia can still decide about daily routines, contact and care, especially with the right support, at the right time of day.

Who is responsible for making decisions for someone with dementia?
Making decisions for someone with dementia falls to whoever is responsible for that decision. A doctor usually decides on treatment, the local authority on care arrangements, and a registered health and welfare attorney where one exists. Family have no automatic right to decide, but the decision-maker must consult them.

What happens when someone with dementia can’t make decisions?
When someone with dementia can’t make a particular decision, the decision-maker must act in their best interests under section 4 of the Mental Capacity Act. That means involving the person, weighing their past and present wishes, consulting family and choosing the least restrictive option. Disputes can be taken to the Court of Protection.

Does dementia mean automatic loss of capacity?
No. Dementia and loss of capacity are linked but not automatic. An assessor must show that the person cannot understand, retain, use or weigh, or communicate information about a specific decision, and that this is because of their dementia. A diagnosis alone never proves incapacity, and an unwise choice is not proof either.

How are dementia best interests decisions made?
Dementia best interests decisions follow the checklist in section 4 of the Mental Capacity Act. The decision-maker must consider whether capacity may return, involve the person, take account of their wishes, beliefs and values, and consult family and carers. The aim is the right decision for the person, not the easiest one for others.

When do dementia and the Court of Protection come together?
Dementia and the Court of Protection usually meet when the family cannot agree. The court can decide disputed capacity, resolve disagreements about care, residence, contact or serious treatment, and authorise care that deprives someone of their liberty outside a care home or hospital. Most decisions never need court, but urgent applications are possible.

Can capacity come back after it has been lost?
Sometimes. Capacity in dementia can fluctuate, and ability may vary with tiredness, infection, pain or the time of day. The law requires decision-makers to consider whether the person may regain capacity and whether the decision can wait. A capacity assessment reflects one decision at one moment.

Is legal aid available for dementia cases in the Court of Protection?

Often, yes. Challenges to a DoLS authorisation under section 21A can qualify for non-means-tested legal aid for the person and their representative. Other health and welfare cases may qualify depending on merits and means. We check eligibility at first contact and handle the application, so families can focus on their relatives.